The final Top 3 contestants for American Idol Season 23 have been announced, but the fanbase remains sharply divided. While some are celebrating their favorites advancing, others argue that key talents were left behind. One thing is certain — this may be the most unpredictable finale in Idol history.
The live semifinal aired on May 12, 2025, and after more than 19 million votes, Jamal Roberts, John Foster, and Breanna Nix secured their places in the finale. Meanwhile, Thunderstorm Artis and Slater Nalley were eliminated in a highly emotional goodbye.
WHO WILL WIN AMERICAN IDOL 2025? LET’S BREAK IT DOWN
With just days left until the May 19 finale, let’s take a closer look at each finalist — their strengths, public support, and what could push them to victory.
🎤 1. JAMAL ROBERTS – THE FRONTRUNNER TO BEAT
Hometown: Meridian, Mississippi
Age: 27
Background: PE teacher, father of three
Genre: Soul / R&B
Why He’s the Favorite:
Electrifying Stage Presence: Jamal’s performances regularly bring crowds to their feet. His rendition of “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough” turned the studio into a celebration.
Judge Acclaim: Lionel Richie said Jamal can “Jamal-ize any song,” while Luke Bryan called his latest performance “one of the best of the season.”
Fan Buzz & Industry Prediction: Media outlets like Reality Tea have pegged Jamal as the front-runner based on his consistency and charisma.
🌟 2. JOHN FOSTER – THE COUNTRY FAN FAVORITE
Hometown: Addis, Louisiana
Age: 18
Genre: Country
🎸 Why He’s Still in the Race:
Authenticity: John’s soulful performance of “Rainbow Connection” and his fun take on “The Bear Necessities” have earned him a strong, loyal following.
Judges’ Feedback: Luke Bryan praised his confidence and originality. Lionel Richie said he’s “endlessly likable,” a key trait for an Idol winner.
Fan Base: Country music fans are showing up for Foster — and their votes could make all the difference on finale night.
3. BREANNA NIX – THE EMOTIONAL POWERHOUSE
Hometown: Denton, Texas
Age: 25
Background: Stay-at-home mom
Genre: Inspirational Pop / Gospel
Why She’s Capturing Hearts:
Vocal Emotion: Breanna connects deeply to every performance, like her heartfelt delivery of “You’ll Be in My Heart.”
Judges’ Praise: Carrie Underwood noted her emotional authenticity, while Lionel Richie praised her ability to shine under pressure.
Support Factor: As the only female finalist, Breanna has gained significant support from viewers who value heart, family, and faith.
FINAL PREDICTION: WHO HAS THE EDGE?
🥇 Jamal Roberts – Currently the strongest contender based on judge feedback, poll data, and social media reactions.
🥈 John Foster – A serious threat to win, especially with the powerful country vote behind him.
🥉 Breanna Nix – An emotional performer with rising momentum, but slightly behind in fan prediction rankings.
